NERFU Collegiate Men's All Stars vs Toulouse University
Friday April 9th, 2010 - 830pm Kickoff
Amesbury Sports Park - http://www.amesburysportspark.net/
12 South Hunt Rd., Amesbury, MA
1. Mark Olsen - Roger Williams
2. Matt Tannozini - University of Rhode Island
3. Greg Wachter - New Haven U/23
4. Matt Woerner - Tufts
5. Niko Retzos - Mass Maritime
6. Shaine Bonin - UMass Lowell
7. Alan Page - Castleton St.
8. Andrew Marullo - Southern Connecticut
9. Dan Rosa - Southern Connecticut
10. Alex Reeves - Worcester Poly Tech
11. Connor Landers - Endicott (Middlesex)
12. Alex Rollins - UMass Dartmouth
13. Ken Stern - Boston University
14. Kyle Odell -Western Connecticut
15. Erik Brierly - University of Rhode Island
16. Mike Bruce - Northeastern University
17. Eric Derba - UMass Lowell
18. Colby Roy - Roger Williams
19. Steve Windward -UMass Lowell
20. Alex Throssel - Northeastern University
21. Gabe Perreone - Tufts
22. Nick Smit - Northeastern University
23. Colin Yip - Boston University
Assistant Coach Dan Mullane explains the plans for the NERFU Selects Program for the spring of 2010.
"We had a tryout in the fall and another in the spring. With a pool of about 110 players, we narrowed it down to around 60 as of now. We didn't make any cuts, only lost players to injury and unavailability for spring matches.
We then named the NERFU All Star side to play Toulouse University on April 9th. Toulouse is a French University touring side. We selected 23 players out of the 60 left in the pool. All other playersn are still in contention to make the NERFU side in the game vs the Ivy All Stars or for the NRU Cup should additional players become injured or unable to participate in the program.
We have 2 matches scheduled before the NRU Cup on 4/25 to help identify players and their skill sets.
On 4/9 we play Toulouse and on Thursday 4/15 we will play the Ivy Leage All Stars @ Mass Maritime.
Our goals are to produce quality players for NRU selectors and to improve the program as much as possible via the tryouts, keeping the player pool open and not making cuts and scheduling these matches before the NRU Cup. Our hope is that this will help keep players coming back next your and hopefully more of their teammates will be interested in trying out for the squad."
Dan Mullane's email: sdanielmullane@hotmail.com
Tuesday, March 30, 2010
Thursday, March 25, 2010
High School Rugby in Massachusetts and New England
Let's start with a currently controversial topic! What is happening in the high school rugby scene in Massachusetts - specifically boys U19?
In the two weeks since I arrived back in Boston after a long trip back to Australia, I've heard a number of sources tell me about the shenanigans going on with high school rugby around Boston. The first guy tells me that there is a Catholic Conference of five schools that has "defected"from USA Rugby (CIPPing) and NERFU.
He tells me this involves five private Catholic schools around Boston, but not including Bishop Hendricken HS because it's not in MA. This information is imparted with numerous expletives, with particular venom reserved for one particular high school head coach. Apparently, this means that these five schools will no longer CIPP their players and no longer play in NERFU sanctioned tournaments. They will play on an "island", so to speak. This would also mean none of the good players could play on Select Sides, USA U19, and other representative player development programs sanctioned by USA Rugby.
Next, I hear from a different source that the Athletic Directors of the five aforementioned schools have realized the error of their ways and decided to re-enlist with USA Rugby and NERFU. Why? Because they realized that no-one outside the Group of Five would ever play them, not being affiliated with the LAU and the national body. This about-face turns out not to be true - a good case of sideline gossip leading me astray.
Next, I speak to the Head Coach of one of the Group of Five (at this point I am hesitant to name names - I want to promote discussion - not vilification). He tells me, with a great scowl and vehemence, what an absolute rotter this other coach is for instigating the Catholic Conference split. He didn't use the word "rotter". This very upset Head Coach is part of the break-away conference, but seems none too happy about it. I will be following up with him soon.
Yesterday, I had an interesting chat with a high school Athletic Director on this subject. I wanted to know more, get his perspective - as presumably he represented the viewpoint of the six (yes, six: Bishop Hendricken HS of Rhode Island is also a member) ADs that form this new conference. The six schools are: Boston College HS, Catholic Memorial, Malden Catholic, Xaverian Brothers HS, St. Johns Prep, Bishop Hendricken HS.
What did he say? I will paraphrase.
"We have an educational mission with our athletics programs that is consistent with the educational mission of our school. We want to expose our student athletes to an environment that is consistent with our educational mission. In our other sports, like football and baseball, we are organized under the auspices of the MIAA - Massachusetts Inter-Scholastic Athletic Association, and we play schools that are members of the MIAA.
However, with rugby we are asked to play U19 rugby clubs that are not affiliated with any high school, are not supported by any institution we recognize. We have community club players showing up at our school in cars, unsupervised. We don't know who they are, where they come from, what age they are, what liability insurance they may or may not have, who their coach is, and so on. This concerns us greatly.
What do we say to parents when a 20 year-old visiting player injures one of our kids? We don't know where he came from, we have no idea if he is even a high school student! Any insurance waiver that kids have signed, with USA Rugby or whomever, will be worthless, utterly worthless in a bad injury scenario of this nature.
Furthermore, we are asked to be organized under the umbrella of organizations like NERFU and USA Rugby that we are not familiar with in our others sports. We are not familiar, and not comfortable with organizations such as NERFU. We are not asked to affiliate with organizations of this structure in our other sports, like baseball and football. One day, the MIAA might recognize rugby as a sport and it will be organized in a fashion we are more comfortable with."
The AD said a lot more than this, but this serves as the kernel of his perspective on the reasons for the break-away Catholic Conference. He also observed that one day soon, rugby playing high schools might petition the MIAA for official recognition. What threshold number of high schools would be sufficient for this to take place? Fifty might be a solid number, he suggested. Then, the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee would consider it, do its research and make a decision. We didn't discuss how long this might take. My impression is that it would take a number of years to be approved. As I don't know for sure, I will endeavor to find out.
Where does this leave us? It seems that it leaves community-based U19 rugby programs out in the cold in Massachusetts, if this trend catches on with other schools playing rugby. Will other private prep schools and high schools adopt the same approach, and refuse to play community U19 clubs? Will two conferences evolve side-by-side but never playing each other? How do we know which high school team is the best? Will any of the Catholic Conference players be selected for representative honors? Does this strengthen or weaken the national player talent development pathways?
N.B. The NERFU website lists 14 high school boys rugby clubs in Massachusetts, including the six in the Catholic Connference. NERFU lists 5 community-based U19 clubs in Massachusetts.
The Athletic Director also told me that the school is not stopping individual players from CIPPing with USA Rugby, and is not stopping individual players from playing on other teams outside the school. For example, a player from his school might decide not to play for the high school and go and play for a community-based U19 club, like Middlesex U19. The AD cited four ice hockey players at his school that do not play for the high school, instead playing for a Juniors hockey club.
You also should know that the Referees' Society (NERRS) is apparently refusing to supply referees to non-affiliated rugby clubs i.e. the entire Catholic Conference. This is because NERRS is a member of NERFU and USA Rugby, and under USA Rugby guidelines cannot sanction games played by clubs that are not CIPPed and not paying dues to their LAU. A source told me that this only means that non-CIPPed clubs do not have access to the NERRS scheduling system, but does not preclude individual referees accepting "private" assignments, such as Catholic Conference games. Maybe the Catholic Conference games will pay more and so attract referees? Is NERRS correct in taking this stance? Is this stance the only legal, safe (read "liability") option NERRS has? Where will the referees come from for the break-away conference?
What will happen next? So many questions. If you think I have erred in matters of fact in the discussion above, please enlighten us. If you can shed light on any aspect, please do. We want to know the truth and we want to promote transparency and progress. I look forward to your comments.
In the two weeks since I arrived back in Boston after a long trip back to Australia, I've heard a number of sources tell me about the shenanigans going on with high school rugby around Boston. The first guy tells me that there is a Catholic Conference of five schools that has "defected"from USA Rugby (CIPPing) and NERFU.
He tells me this involves five private Catholic schools around Boston, but not including Bishop Hendricken HS because it's not in MA. This information is imparted with numerous expletives, with particular venom reserved for one particular high school head coach. Apparently, this means that these five schools will no longer CIPP their players and no longer play in NERFU sanctioned tournaments. They will play on an "island", so to speak. This would also mean none of the good players could play on Select Sides, USA U19, and other representative player development programs sanctioned by USA Rugby.
Next, I hear from a different source that the Athletic Directors of the five aforementioned schools have realized the error of their ways and decided to re-enlist with USA Rugby and NERFU. Why? Because they realized that no-one outside the Group of Five would ever play them, not being affiliated with the LAU and the national body. This about-face turns out not to be true - a good case of sideline gossip leading me astray.
Next, I speak to the Head Coach of one of the Group of Five (at this point I am hesitant to name names - I want to promote discussion - not vilification). He tells me, with a great scowl and vehemence, what an absolute rotter this other coach is for instigating the Catholic Conference split. He didn't use the word "rotter". This very upset Head Coach is part of the break-away conference, but seems none too happy about it. I will be following up with him soon.
Yesterday, I had an interesting chat with a high school Athletic Director on this subject. I wanted to know more, get his perspective - as presumably he represented the viewpoint of the six (yes, six: Bishop Hendricken HS of Rhode Island is also a member) ADs that form this new conference. The six schools are: Boston College HS, Catholic Memorial, Malden Catholic, Xaverian Brothers HS, St. Johns Prep, Bishop Hendricken HS.
What did he say? I will paraphrase.
"We have an educational mission with our athletics programs that is consistent with the educational mission of our school. We want to expose our student athletes to an environment that is consistent with our educational mission. In our other sports, like football and baseball, we are organized under the auspices of the MIAA - Massachusetts Inter-Scholastic Athletic Association, and we play schools that are members of the MIAA.
However, with rugby we are asked to play U19 rugby clubs that are not affiliated with any high school, are not supported by any institution we recognize. We have community club players showing up at our school in cars, unsupervised. We don't know who they are, where they come from, what age they are, what liability insurance they may or may not have, who their coach is, and so on. This concerns us greatly.
What do we say to parents when a 20 year-old visiting player injures one of our kids? We don't know where he came from, we have no idea if he is even a high school student! Any insurance waiver that kids have signed, with USA Rugby or whomever, will be worthless, utterly worthless in a bad injury scenario of this nature.
Furthermore, we are asked to be organized under the umbrella of organizations like NERFU and USA Rugby that we are not familiar with in our others sports. We are not familiar, and not comfortable with organizations such as NERFU. We are not asked to affiliate with organizations of this structure in our other sports, like baseball and football. One day, the MIAA might recognize rugby as a sport and it will be organized in a fashion we are more comfortable with."
The AD said a lot more than this, but this serves as the kernel of his perspective on the reasons for the break-away Catholic Conference. He also observed that one day soon, rugby playing high schools might petition the MIAA for official recognition. What threshold number of high schools would be sufficient for this to take place? Fifty might be a solid number, he suggested. Then, the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee would consider it, do its research and make a decision. We didn't discuss how long this might take. My impression is that it would take a number of years to be approved. As I don't know for sure, I will endeavor to find out.
Where does this leave us? It seems that it leaves community-based U19 rugby programs out in the cold in Massachusetts, if this trend catches on with other schools playing rugby. Will other private prep schools and high schools adopt the same approach, and refuse to play community U19 clubs? Will two conferences evolve side-by-side but never playing each other? How do we know which high school team is the best? Will any of the Catholic Conference players be selected for representative honors? Does this strengthen or weaken the national player talent development pathways?
N.B. The NERFU website lists 14 high school boys rugby clubs in Massachusetts, including the six in the Catholic Connference. NERFU lists 5 community-based U19 clubs in Massachusetts.
The Athletic Director also told me that the school is not stopping individual players from CIPPing with USA Rugby, and is not stopping individual players from playing on other teams outside the school. For example, a player from his school might decide not to play for the high school and go and play for a community-based U19 club, like Middlesex U19. The AD cited four ice hockey players at his school that do not play for the high school, instead playing for a Juniors hockey club.
You also should know that the Referees' Society (NERRS) is apparently refusing to supply referees to non-affiliated rugby clubs i.e. the entire Catholic Conference. This is because NERRS is a member of NERFU and USA Rugby, and under USA Rugby guidelines cannot sanction games played by clubs that are not CIPPed and not paying dues to their LAU. A source told me that this only means that non-CIPPed clubs do not have access to the NERRS scheduling system, but does not preclude individual referees accepting "private" assignments, such as Catholic Conference games. Maybe the Catholic Conference games will pay more and so attract referees? Is NERRS correct in taking this stance? Is this stance the only legal, safe (read "liability") option NERRS has? Where will the referees come from for the break-away conference?
What will happen next? So many questions. If you think I have erred in matters of fact in the discussion above, please enlighten us. If you can shed light on any aspect, please do. We want to know the truth and we want to promote transparency and progress. I look forward to your comments.
Welcome to Coach Fred Clark's Rugby Blog
Welcome! After seven years of involvement in rugby in the United States, I've decided to start a blog. A cursory Google search reveals a number of rugby blogs out there. Not many are up to date, and many of them spout uninformed opinions on every subject, often with little or no relation to the "facts on the ground", as Donald Rumsfeld liked to say; in fact the best active rugby blogs appear to be about women's rugby in the US. The active, quality blogs that I find will be linked from this one.
The reason I am becoming a "blogger" is simply this: accurate information. I have observed countless times that no-one has a clue what is happening outside their little patch of rugby. For example, a player or coach may know about club activities, maybe a few things about the union pertaining to his/her club, and not much else.
Facts, trends, decisions and events that affect us all are often shared on the sidelines among friends - and an awful amount of gossip and misinformation is spread there too. I love a good natter while I am watching the game, but please, somebody, give me the hard facts. I like to know what is going on - but too often it takes ten conversations over six months to get it all straight. This blog will attempt to present an objective perspective on a range of rugby issues, with information sourced from the people that know the facts. Your contributions are welcome - I look forward to it. Let the dialogue begin!
The reason I am becoming a "blogger" is simply this: accurate information. I have observed countless times that no-one has a clue what is happening outside their little patch of rugby. For example, a player or coach may know about club activities, maybe a few things about the union pertaining to his/her club, and not much else.
Facts, trends, decisions and events that affect us all are often shared on the sidelines among friends - and an awful amount of gossip and misinformation is spread there too. I love a good natter while I am watching the game, but please, somebody, give me the hard facts. I like to know what is going on - but too often it takes ten conversations over six months to get it all straight. This blog will attempt to present an objective perspective on a range of rugby issues, with information sourced from the people that know the facts. Your contributions are welcome - I look forward to it. Let the dialogue begin!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
