Let's start with a currently controversial topic! What is happening in the high school rugby scene in Massachusetts - specifically boys U19?
In the two weeks since I arrived back in Boston after a long trip back to Australia, I've heard a number of sources tell me about the shenanigans going on with high school rugby around Boston. The first guy tells me that there is a Catholic Conference of five schools that has "defected"from USA Rugby (CIPPing) and NERFU.
He tells me this involves five private Catholic schools around Boston, but not including Bishop Hendricken HS because it's not in MA. This information is imparted with numerous expletives, with particular venom reserved for one particular high school head coach. Apparently, this means that these five schools will no longer CIPP their players and no longer play in NERFU sanctioned tournaments. They will play on an "island", so to speak. This would also mean none of the good players could play on Select Sides, USA U19, and other representative player development programs sanctioned by USA Rugby.
Next, I hear from a different source that the Athletic Directors of the five aforementioned schools have realized the error of their ways and decided to re-enlist with USA Rugby and NERFU. Why? Because they realized that no-one outside the Group of Five would ever play them, not being affiliated with the LAU and the national body. This about-face turns out not to be true - a good case of sideline gossip leading me astray.
Next, I speak to the Head Coach of one of the Group of Five (at this point I am hesitant to name names - I want to promote discussion - not vilification). He tells me, with a great scowl and vehemence, what an absolute rotter this other coach is for instigating the Catholic Conference split. He didn't use the word "rotter". This very upset Head Coach is part of the break-away conference, but seems none too happy about it. I will be following up with him soon.
Yesterday, I had an interesting chat with a high school Athletic Director on this subject. I wanted to know more, get his perspective - as presumably he represented the viewpoint of the six (yes, six: Bishop Hendricken HS of Rhode Island is also a member) ADs that form this new conference. The six schools are: Boston College HS, Catholic Memorial, Malden Catholic, Xaverian Brothers HS, St. Johns Prep, Bishop Hendricken HS.
What did he say? I will paraphrase.
"We have an educational mission with our athletics programs that is consistent with the educational mission of our school. We want to expose our student athletes to an environment that is consistent with our educational mission. In our other sports, like football and baseball, we are organized under the auspices of the MIAA - Massachusetts Inter-Scholastic Athletic Association, and we play schools that are members of the MIAA.
However, with rugby we are asked to play U19 rugby clubs that are not affiliated with any high school, are not supported by any institution we recognize. We have community club players showing up at our school in cars, unsupervised. We don't know who they are, where they come from, what age they are, what liability insurance they may or may not have, who their coach is, and so on. This concerns us greatly.
What do we say to parents when a 20 year-old visiting player injures one of our kids? We don't know where he came from, we have no idea if he is even a high school student! Any insurance waiver that kids have signed, with USA Rugby or whomever, will be worthless, utterly worthless in a bad injury scenario of this nature.
Furthermore, we are asked to be organized under the umbrella of organizations like NERFU and USA Rugby that we are not familiar with in our others sports. We are not familiar, and not comfortable with organizations such as NERFU. We are not asked to affiliate with organizations of this structure in our other sports, like baseball and football. One day, the MIAA might recognize rugby as a sport and it will be organized in a fashion we are more comfortable with."
The AD said a lot more than this, but this serves as the kernel of his perspective on the reasons for the break-away Catholic Conference. He also observed that one day soon, rugby playing high schools might petition the MIAA for official recognition. What threshold number of high schools would be sufficient for this to take place? Fifty might be a solid number, he suggested. Then, the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee would consider it, do its research and make a decision. We didn't discuss how long this might take. My impression is that it would take a number of years to be approved. As I don't know for sure, I will endeavor to find out.
Where does this leave us? It seems that it leaves community-based U19 rugby programs out in the cold in Massachusetts, if this trend catches on with other schools playing rugby. Will other private prep schools and high schools adopt the same approach, and refuse to play community U19 clubs? Will two conferences evolve side-by-side but never playing each other? How do we know which high school team is the best? Will any of the Catholic Conference players be selected for representative honors? Does this strengthen or weaken the national player talent development pathways?
N.B. The NERFU website lists 14 high school boys rugby clubs in Massachusetts, including the six in the Catholic Connference. NERFU lists 5 community-based U19 clubs in Massachusetts.
The Athletic Director also told me that the school is not stopping individual players from CIPPing with USA Rugby, and is not stopping individual players from playing on other teams outside the school. For example, a player from his school might decide not to play for the high school and go and play for a community-based U19 club, like Middlesex U19. The AD cited four ice hockey players at his school that do not play for the high school, instead playing for a Juniors hockey club.
You also should know that the Referees' Society (NERRS) is apparently refusing to supply referees to non-affiliated rugby clubs i.e. the entire Catholic Conference. This is because NERRS is a member of NERFU and USA Rugby, and under USA Rugby guidelines cannot sanction games played by clubs that are not CIPPed and not paying dues to their LAU. A source told me that this only means that non-CIPPed clubs do not have access to the NERRS scheduling system, but does not preclude individual referees accepting "private" assignments, such as Catholic Conference games. Maybe the Catholic Conference games will pay more and so attract referees? Is NERRS correct in taking this stance? Is this stance the only legal, safe (read "liability") option NERRS has? Where will the referees come from for the break-away conference?
What will happen next? So many questions. If you think I have erred in matters of fact in the discussion above, please enlighten us. If you can shed light on any aspect, please do. We want to know the truth and we want to promote transparency and progress. I look forward to your comments.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

After reading through, the case seems solid on several points: if a high school player received an injury from a club player, there would be a huge debate as to liability. The typical end to these debates? NO ONE takes responsibility. Also, nationally controlled, but not school controlled, sports have a tendency (at least in the States) of spiraling out of control into a chaotic mess of poor organization and poor sportsmanship.
ReplyDeleteWith that said, I don;t buy that these facts play at all into the decision to split. They make a decent cover story - but when the only deflecting schools are Jesuit it begins to appear a more calculated attempt to seize control from a centralized body.
In the end, my guess is someone's trying a coup...one that will certainly fail, but one that won;t soon be deserted. The good news - decent players will continue to play club as recruitment always makes it more fun (and alluring) to play outside of a school setting.
See you at practice tonight coach!
Considering you are an asst.coach for one of thes Catholic Conference teams Mr. Clark what is your position?
ReplyDeleteThanks for the question, Anonymous. Yes, since early last week I have been helping to coach one of the schools mentioned in this blog topic. The school in question, incidentally, has 80-100 boys in its program and employs four paid coaches, of which I became the fourth last week. A mighty impressive group they are too.
ReplyDeleteMy position, both as the moderator of this discussion and as the employee of the school's rugby program, is to reserve judgement for the moment. Rugby is in its nascent stages in the US, with many emerging trends and philosophies.
I only recently read about the emergence of State Based Organizations (SBOs) that will run youth rugby in each state. I notice Caifornia and now Massachusetts are having teething problems: California with how its registration system synchronizes with the national CIPP database, and Massachusetts with the issue raised in this topic.
Yes, I am cautiously taking the diplomatic path because I don't see how it benefits any of us to claim ultimate expertise on this matter. I want rugby to flourish and I'm not wedded to a particular model.
I can confidently predict that the new six-team conference will probably grow to become the strongest high school rugby conference on the East Coast. They have an 8-game schedule this spring, with three of the schools playing each other home and away to fill up the schedule. This is similar to the schedule played in the 100-year old private school conference in Sydney, Australia (the GPS, or Great Public Schools), where I learned my rugby.
Where does that leave the other U19 clubs in NERFU(about 30 clubs on the NERFU website outside the break-away conference of six)? Perhaps in a Division II with the possibility of promotion /relegation. I don't see why a strong high school like Brookline High, or Arlington Catholic High School wouldn't apply to join the break-away conference.
I think there may be resolution to be found in this new conference of six continuing to be members of NERFU and also CIPPing with USA Rugby, while continuing to run an independent conference that the six schools are confortable with. These are only suggestions, but we must think of some ideas if we are to progress.
From my experience in Sydney playing in a 100-year old conference of private schools, I know it would be almost unthinkable for my alma mater, The Scots College to think of playing a U19 community-based club that runs around in the local park with perhaps no coach, and without any recognizable institutional backing. Perhaps the community-based clubs need to find institutional backing; perhaps YMCAs or Girls & Boys Clubs would be appropriate. This might go a long way to assuaging the concerns of the above-mentioned private schools.
Fred Clark
thanks for answering Mr. Clark.
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting that these Catholic schools are citing an issue of liability on the part club players/clubs that they may be playing *and* that they are not familiar with USA Rugby.
ReplyDeleteAnyone who's been USA Rugby certified in coaching youth rugby would know that having U-19 teams play older club teams is ill-advised.
It's a shame that rugby is being compared to other sports when it is so much more in so many ways, especially in regard to it's potential to build community and commraderie where there otherwise would be none.
Hello Anonymous.
ReplyDeleteI don't think anybody suggested that U19 teams are, or should be playing older club teams. I think the liability concern is in the lack of information about who is playing on a community-based U19 team. Are the players all U19? Are they high school students at all? Could a 20 year-old player show up one day and nobody notice - until somebody gets hurt?
It's this almost complete absence of information and lack of recognizable institutional backing that is a concern for these schools, I believe.
I agree with you that rugby is so much more than "just another sport", but then we would say that. I always regale my players with stories of playing in other countries, of trips to World Cups and Test matches, of the global family that is rugby.
My favorite is the guy from Sydney on a surfing safari in Europe. After surfing in France he make his way into Portgual looking for some waves. He finds himself in a small fishing village on the coast, where he books into a hostel and goes surfing.
He meets the local rugby club guys in a bar. Within a week they have him playing, tending bar for a part-time job, free accommodation in somebody's spare room, and probably a girlfriend as well. He stayed a year.
The difficult issue of the break-away high school rugby conference in Massachusetts that doesn't want to be associated with USA Rugby or NERFU raises some thorny issues. There appear to be two sides of the argument (though I couldn't be sure there aren't more).
ReplyDeleteThe high schools argue they have excellent insurance policies already that cover their own players, visiting players, and presumably coaches, referees and spectatators as well, against injury. Why then would they need a USA Rugby stipulated insurance policy to cover "third party" injury or damage? Why do these high school rugby programs need to be members of USA Rugby and the Local Area Union (LAU) - NERFU, at all?
As I understand it, USA Rugby (and its member union NERFU) argue that they, the governing bodies of rugby, cannot sanction a game between a non-member club against a member club because officials themselves might be sued.
If a high school already has a great insurance policy, the argument goes, why does it need another, mandated by an outside organization it has never dealt with before, and in a structural arrangement that obtains in none of its other sports? Why is rugby different from baseball or basketball in Massachusetts or in any other state?
Does the high school insurance policy cover NERFU officials if the rugby governing body (NERFU) sanctions a fixture between a member and a non-member? Can NERFU sanction a game without any risk of being sued, as an organization or for its officers?
What does the USA Rugby insurance policy cover? Is it connected with the CIPP membership fee?
For those readers not aware, USA Rugby and its member unions require that every player and coach and referee be registered with the national body (USA Rugby) to be able to participate in sanctioned rugby matches in the USA. This is called the CIPP - the "Club and Individual Participation Program", or CIPP.
According to the USA Rugby website, the CIPP membership fee for registered players, coupled with the Waiver form, provides insurance cover, through USA Rugby's global policy for "third party" damage to a field, or to spectators, or to facilities if there is an "incident".
"Perhaps the most visible of the USA Rugby member benefits, liability insurance provides liability protection in case of property damage or bodily injury to third parties. These parties may include the venue owner, coaches, referees, sponsors, spectators and others. Most venue owners will require this type of insurance before a club is allowed to step on the field of play." (USA Rugby website)
The USA Rugby website further cites a letter from their insurance provider, ESIX Insurance:
"USA Rugby’s General Liability insurance provider relies on a signed Waiver and Release to defend an allegation of negligence which results in injury. The Waiver:
1. Contractually obligates the athlete and/or parent not to sue the organization
2. Many do not consider litigation with the knowledge that they have signed a Waiver and Release
3. Provides a first method of defense against allegations of negligence
4. Most sports require a signed Waiver in order to participate"
What is really going on here? I have heard the opinion expressed that the CIPP fee has nothing to do with insurance and is simply a revenue source for USA Rugby. Apparently 20% of its revenue comes from U19 CIPP fees.
Are LAU officials really at risk of being sued? Or, is the appropriate analogy more a labor union type issue where the paid up members object to scab labor changing the pay and conditions - about power and control?
Can the CIPP be regarded as a tax on participants to pay for the game's development at the grass roots? Is this a fair trade ($20 a year for kids) to grow the game we love? Are we asking the right questions? You tell me.
Sources: USA Rugby, www.usarugby.org
ESIX Insurance, www.esixglobal.com